
By Christine Richard
Sure, a lot of people go to Point Reyes National Seashore in Northern California
for recreation — hiking, biking, horseback riding. This map is full
of trails for those fit types, but I’ve invented my own trail for an activity I love: oyster-eating.
Plus, January and February are the months to go raw (in the summer, opt for barbecue) along the coast of this wild region approximately an hour north of San Francisco.
Oyster stop 1: Coast Café
Where: Bolinas
Atmosphere: California
neo-hippie beachy eclectic with a nice wine list.
Oysters: Drake's Bay oysters and chips.
FYI: the restaurant advertises mesquite barbecued oysters on the porch on
summer weekends.
Price: $13 for Drake's Bay oysters and chips (this
was a special).
Outcome: Upsetting. After 25 minutes of waiting for my order
to be taken, I finally asked the server (who was doing paperwork at the cash
register for the full 25 minutes) if I could have my bill for my soda.
Would I go back? Since I turned my back on these oysters,
I’ve been thinking about them. I’d love to go back. The manager comped my coke
and apologized.
Oyster stop 2: Farm House Restaurant
Where: Olema
Atmosphere: Roadhouse-y with more panache. Built in 1865.
Bar/dining area has a window that overlooks a portion of wee Olema.
Oysters: Drake's Bay served raw, grilled
with herbs and garlic, and grilled with citrus barbecue
sauce.
Price: 6 oysters for $9.50. One oyster is like the size of a
small fish, though, so you get a lot of meat for the price.
Pairing: Lost Coast’s Great White (I LOVE this beer).
Outcome: Raw rules and these were fresh. More creamy than briny, perhaps because of its size. This particular Drake’s Bay
oyster variety was big. Really big. I’m not convinced
that I want an oyster to be this big. If I wanted this much oyster, I’d order
an oyster steak. Nice selection of salads and local cheeses on the menu. Comfortable place to slurp. How can you not like a Victorian wooden storefront with a white picket fence (and oysters)?
Non shellfish diversion: Inverness
After leaving Olema and heading north, take a left at Bear Valley Road. Stop in at the Visitors Center for trail maps, area maps, books on birds, a quick
walk on the earthquake trail, etc. There are also wildlife exhibits. A visitors center so interesting that you almost could spend the day indoors here.
Continue on Bear Valley to Sir Francis
Drake (follow the signs to the lighthouse). You’ll drive through Inverness, a town
that is on the west shores of Tomales Bay and backed by forest, criss crossed by trails. I like it here: houses are on stilts
over the bay and others are wood-shingled hidden in the forest. Stop in at
Spirit Matters and the oddly geographically located Vladimir’s
Czech Restaurant. Barnaby’s restaurant is down the
road a couple miles and has oysters but I’ve yet to check it out (closed when I went).
Oyster stop 3: Station House Restaurant
Where: Point Reyes Station
Atmosphere: The after-6 town hall of PRS. I met the musician, the general manager, the weekend clammer (dirty fingernails gave him away), the walker/author (planetwalker).
Oysters: raw, barbecued or fried (and oyster stew), from Drake's Bay and Tomales.
Price: $23 for a dozen on the half shell.
Pairing: Chardonnay and, again, Great White.
Outcome: Concentrate on the oysters. The popovers are
interesting and tasty and corn-y. The sourdough bread is great, and the cheese board, with Point Reyes cheeses, is delicious, albeit
expensive ($14.95) for the meager portion (seems to be the way with cheese boards these days). It also has Tomales Bay clams and mussels. Skip the calamari
(bland) and the dessert (mine was freezer burned).
Non shellfish diversion: Point Reyes Vineyard
About a five-minute car ride north of Point Reyes Station is
Point Reyes Vineyard, where your first look won’t be of vines but of cows grazing
on the grass. Taste three sparkling wines for $5. The tasting room is only open
on weekends.
Shellfish PICNIC: Tomales Bay Company
and Hog Island
Both of these oyster farms, located north of Point Reyes
Station on Highway 1 between Tomales Bay State Park and Marshall,
sell directly to eaters with large shucking knives.
I stopped in to see what was going on but didn’t
participate. Here’s what happens: You buy raw oysters in quantity, shuck them
yourself, then eat them raw or grill them (or you can carry them away).
Both places provide shucking
equipment, grills and picnic tables. This could be loads of fun with more than
four people. I was traveling alone. It would have been sad. Reservations are needed in the summer for the grills, I'm told.
ALSO: Tony’s Seafood
Facing Tomales Bay before you come to The Marshall Store (if you’re traveling north).
Unfortunately, Tony’s was closed most of December. Next time.
**OYSTER-OBSESSED AUTHOR'S FAVORITE
Oyster stop 4 The Marshall Store (Frankly,
I’m disappointed they have a Web site; makes it feel like less of a find.)
Where: Marshall
Atmosphere: This is where a true oyster eater eats—right in the
environment, overlooking Tomales Bay, sailboats and a
gorgeous slice of landscape (yes, it looks cloudy but so?). There are absolutely no pretenses here. If you
don’t like it, don’t let the screen door hit you in the ...
Oysters: raw, barbecued or Rockefeller.
Price: a magnificent $8 for a half dozen.
Pairing: Get down on your knees and drink the wonderful water of Tomales Bay that breeds these
beautiful shellfish. Then, order a beer.
Outcome: I'm a purist. Raw wins. The barbecue had too much cocktail
sauce on it, which masks the flavor of the oyster. The Marshall Store
also has serve-yourself Tomales Bay clam chowder in three
sizes, Tall, Venti, Grande … not really. I wish I could buy the place next door and eat oysters for breakfast. These oysters were the bomb.
Oyster stop 5: Nick’s Cove
Where: Marshall
Atmosphere: Like a lake/forest lodge that was hand-built by
your great grandfather to hang all his trophy catches, including those deer and moose. Then, maybe he decided to
add an upscale oyster bar. Don't know if white linen is the norm but when I went (Christmas Eve) it was in full force; there are also cabins where you can stay overnight.
Oysters: Tomales Bay and Drake's Bay, and rotating other provenances, served raw, barbecued, cornmeal fried.
Price: $2 per on the half shell; $13 for half dozen
barbecued and for cornmeal fried.
Pairing: Blanc de
Blancs Point Reyes Vineyard sparkling (plus about a dozen other Marin County wines on the list).
Outcome: Switcheroo. I ordered two each of the Preston
Point, Kumamotos, Marin Miyagi, Hog Island Sweetwaters, Drake’s Bay Estero,
intending to eliminate and appoint my favorite oyster the king of all. Unfortunately, the
bartender, along with a random server, and the shucker seemed to keep giving me the runaround
on which oyster I was eating. (The regular shucker was out). I had fun nonetheless. And the Drake’s Bay here were MUCH smaller than
the ones at Olema (and tastier). Oyster occasions can be dress down affairs or dress up. This is for the dressed up occasion: you know, bubbles, oysters, trophy deer heads.